The article investigates if you can retire in India with only 25x your expenses saved as retirement corpus.
Who would have a pension plus mutual fund portfolio?
One good example is NPS investors who will need to utilize at least 40% of their NPS corpus as an annuity when they withdraw at 60. The remaining NPS corpus may be invested in any product of choice.
Another example of such portfolios belongs to investors who have:
purchased deferred annuities when they were earning income before retirement
have voluntarily decided to purchase an annuity either at the start or at the end of retirement
have received a windfall from a property or other sale or inheritance and have decided to safeguard that corpus via an annuity purchase
We will consider below an investor who has decided to invest 40% of their retirement corpus at age 60 into a 5%/year annuity taxable at 30%, while the remaining 60% of the portfolio is invested into an equity index fund.
The annuity will fund a part of the monthly expenses while the rest will come out of the equity mutual fund via SWP. Due to the lack of data for the Indian market, we use Monte Carlo simulation using Nifty 50 Total returns index data since 1999 to model 1,000 retirement paths for SWR ranging from 1% to 5% at 0.5% intervals.
Defining SIP, SWP and STP
All of these are standing instructions that get executed as per a schedule you specify:
Systematic Investment Plan (SIP): Money from a bank account is invested into a mutual fund, typically once a month
Systematic Transfer Plan (SIP): Units from a mutual fund are redeemed to invest in another mutual fund of the same AMC
Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP): This is the reverse of the SIP. You sell the units from a mutual fund to send money to a bank account
In this article, we will see if you can have an SWP during retirement to fund in-retirement expenses and see what happens if there is a pension plan. Here the success criterion is:
being able to keep up with inflation. We will assume 7% inflation during retirement. At this rate, costs double in around ten years.
not to run out of money before dying. We will assume 30 years in retirement
There is a caveat that the pension plan will continue to pay throughout retirement, until the day you die, even if the equity corpus goes down to zero.
Did you know that we have a private Facebook group which you can join for free and ask your own questions? Please click the button below to join.
What is the effect of having a pension plan in retirement?
As we see in the diagram, the blue part is the retirement corpus that first rises and then falls. The red dashed line is the pension income that becomes a floor value for income in retirement. No matter how much the rest of the corpus fluctuates, the income does not go down to zero. However, due to inflation and tax, the value of the pension may not be much. If we assume a 7% inflation rate, the value of a ₹50,000/month pension, which requires an investment of ₹1.4 crores approximately at 5% returns and a 15% effective tax rate,
₹50,000/month in Year 1
₹25,000/month in Year 11 (purchasing power cut by half due to 7% inflation)
₹12,500/month in Year 21 (purchasing power cut by half again)
and so on
Therefore, even when the starting value is decent, the purchasing power of the annuity drops rapidly with time.
We will assume that the first year’s withdrawal to be a value between 1% and 5%. The withdrawal amount will be increased by inflation every year. As a practical example, we will take
starting portfolio of one crore with 40% in an annuity (3.5% return post-tax) and 60% in equity index fund
₹2.5 lakhs expense in year one; 2.5 * 1.07 = ₹2.675 lakhs expense in year two etc.
the annuity funds 3.5% of 40 lakhs / 12 = ₹11,667 per month for life. This is purchased as a fixed annuity with a joint payout that runs until the death of the last spouse
since SWP is a standing instruction, we will edit the withdrawal amount in the mutual fund portal once a year to adjust for inflation
Start
₹ 1,00,00,000
Net withdrawal from MF
Withdrawals ⬇️
–
–
Year 1
₹ 2,50,000 - ₹ 1,40,000
₹1,10,000
Year 2
₹ 2,67,500 - ₹ 1,40,000
₹1,27,500
Year 3
₹ 2,86,225 - ₹ 1,40,000
₹1,46,225
Year 4
₹ 3,06,261 - ₹ 1,40,000
₹1,66,261
Year 5
₹ 3,27,699 - ₹ 1,40,000
₹1,87,699
We define “success” as ending with a non-zero portfolio, i.e. not running out of money, after a 30-year retirement with an SWR between 1% and 5%. As per the definition of SWR, the starting portfolio value is 1/SWR. So in terms of the first year’s expenses, a 4% SWR is 1/4% = 25x expenses.
Example: success case
This case leaves behind a ₹4 crores corpus for the heirs.
(click to open in a new tab)
Example: failure case
This case runs out of money around 3/4th time into retirement.
(click to open in a new tab)
However, given that the pension is active, the family continues to earn ₹140,000/year as a pension.
We ran 1,000 such simulations for each of the SWRs (1-5%) and calculated the number of cases where there is a non-zero portfolio value after 30 years with a starting portfolio value of one crore.
(click to open in a new tab)
Here the “Nearly failed” case is equal to an ending value less than or equal to one-fourth of the starting value. Since the starting portfolio is ₹1 crore, any ending value less than ₹25 lakhs is a near-miss. At 7% inflation, this ₹25 lakhs has lost its purchasing power to just ₹3.2 lakhs in 30 years and will, depending on the SWR, pay for only a few months to a year of retirement expense in the 31st year.
adding a pension plan dramatically lowers the chances of completing retirement
the gap vs equity only portfolio lowers at lower SWRs but at such low SWR levels, there is enough wealth to make the investor ambivalent about the choices
If you are investing a lot in NPS for retirement, ensure that you accumulate enough to reach the stage when the SWR is low enough. If it is not, you will reach an unenviable position when you are forced to take the annuity and that makes it even less likely to complete retirement successfully.
Is there a way to take an SWP from equity but yet get guaranteed income via pension?
The following article takes a different approach. Instead of a fixed percentage SWP, it implements a variable one equal to the dividend yield of the equity portfolio and uses those dividends to buy a pension plan every year.
we have assumed that the next 30 years behave like the previous 30. Any changes in how the relative risk and returns of the stock market will change the result considerably
the Monte Carlo simulation assumes that the returns follow a Normal distribution where falls are just as likely as rises in the market. In the real stock market, falls are more frequent or further than rises
we have assumed that the annuity returns 5% pre-tax. As India matures as an economy, we will expect annuity returns to lower further. This interest rate fall will make purchasing an annuity a worse proposition
What's next? You can join the Arthgyaan WhatsApp community
You can stay updated on our latest content and learn about our webinars.
Our community is fully private so that no one, other than the admin, can see your name or number. Also, we will not spam you.
For resident Indians 🇮🇳:
For NRIs 🇺🇸🇬🇧🇪🇺🇦🇺🇦🇪🇸🇬:
Share on WhatsApp:
To understand how this article can help you:
If you have a comment or question about this article
The following button will open a form with the link of this page populated for context:
If you liked this article, please leave us a rating
Disclaimer: Content on this site is for educational purpose only and is not financial advice. Nothing on this site should be construed as an offer or recommendation to buy/sell any financial product or service. Please consult a registered investment advisor before making any investments.
This post titled How to mix an SWP from an equity mutual fund with a pension plan in retirement? first appeared on 09 Oct 2022 at https://arthgyaan.com
