« How Net Present Value (NPV) Can Help You Make Smarter Financial Decisions Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB): Which Series is Best for You? »

Term Insurance with Return of Premium: a Complete Waste of Money

Posted on 23 Aug 2023
Author: Sayan Sircar

Tags: Insurance

13 mins read
📢Join 3500+ readers on WhatsApp and get new post notifications!

This article explains why Term insurance with return of premium (TROP) is more expensive and wastes money that you should invest instead.

Term Insurance with Return of Premium: a Complete Waste of Money

📚 Topics covered:

Introduction
Do you want to invest with your insurance company?
What is NPV and how to understand it?
Comparing TROP with pure term insurance

Introduction

Term insurance with return of premium (TROP) is a trap that wastes money. Insurance companies and their agents make the least amount of money from selling term insurance plans. Therefore, the TROP is an “innovation” that answers the fear of the insurance buyer that “I will not get any returns if I don’t die”. The return of premium policy has a simple pitch:

“In case you don’t die, you get some/all of the premium paid back at the end”.

We will first address this part: getting returns from insurance. Insurance is a pure risk transfer mechanism. Everyone dies but few people die while they are still working before the age of 60. The insurance company collects say ₹10,000/year premiums from everyone and pays the coverage amount of ₹1 crore to the few people who die that year. The cheapest product that can do this is term insurance.

Every other life insurance product, whether TROP, endowment, whole life or ULIP takes this basic core term plan and adds an investment component on top of it. Unfortunately, this investment part of the policy generally has too low returns and are mis-sold to customers who do not know better.

We have covered a few such mistakes in buying term insurance here: Do not make these common mistakes while buying a term insurance policy.

Do you want to invest with your insurance company?

Would you eat Ghasitaram’s chocolate? — my MBA marketing professor

Ghasitaram is a placeholder for a quintessential Indian confectioner whose speciality is Indian sweets. In a world where Hershey’s, Toblerone, and Cadbury exists, would you walk into a Ghasitaram outlet specifically to buy chocolate?

Similarly, would you hire your night watchman to be your personal chef during the day since thieves are expected to come only at night?

Then why invest through insurance companies if banks, mutual funds, PPF, real estate, gold and other investment options exist? After all, though you are getting returns from your non-term life insurance policy, the premium is higher than a pure term policy. The difference of the premium is therefore invested and there is nothing stopping you to take a term plan and invest on your own in any investment of your choice.

Also, would you, and this is the main argument against TROP, pay 40-50% extra salary to your security guard and ask him to return the money after a year if no thieves come?

To understand why TROP is a wastage of money, we will utilise the concept of NPV and compare TROP with pure term policies using NPV.

Did you know that we have a private Facebook group which you can join for free and ask your own questions? Please click the button below to join.

Also read
How can you pay the least interest and get the most tax deduction on your home loan?

What is NPV and how to understand it?

NPV Application In Real Life

Net Present Value (NPV) is a finance concept that will change how you decide between different financial decisions. Since money is worth more today than in the future, a concept as the Time Value of Money, different amounts of money spent or received in the future in the case of two different financial decisions cannot be added and compared directly.

Instead we can use a discounting rate, like FD or PPF rate, to calculate the present value of such cashflows, add them up and calculate which option has the higher present value (NPV).

We have covered the concept of NPV in detail in this article: How Net Present Value (NPV) Can Help You Make Smarter Financial Decisions.

Comparing TROP with pure term insurance

Here we have obtained insurance quotes for a 30-year old salaried male non-smoker with regular premium payment plan until the age of 60. The policy ends at 60.

The pure or normal term plan, for ₹1 crore coverage, is ₹10,593 with GST while the TROP version costs ₹18,880 with GST from the same insurance company. The difference of the premium is ₹8,287. These quotes are from Policybazaar website on the date of publishing this article from the same insurer.

In our NPV calculation we have assumed a discount rate of 7% which is similar to that of PPF. We are comparing two situations via NPV calculation:

buying TROP for ₹18,880
buying normal insurance for ₹10,593 and investing the difference of ₹8,287/year in PPF

Premium is paid for 30 years.

If you live until 60

In case of the TROP, all the premiums, apart from the 18% GST, is returned after 30 years. This amount is 40 * ₹18,880 / 1.18 = ₹4.8 lakhs. The 1.18 factor adjusts for the GST which is not returned.

In case of the term + PPF option, the PPF corpus grows to ₹8.37 lakhs.

In both cases, the NPV comes as a negative number since the insurance company, and not you, benefit when you don’t die. However, with the normal + PPF case, the NPV is less negative and is therefore better.

Year	TROP	Normal + PPF
1	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
2	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
3	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
4	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
5	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
6	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
7	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
8	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
9	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
10	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
11	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
12	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
13	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
14	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
15	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
16	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
17	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
18	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
19	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
20	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
21	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
22	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
23	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
24	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
25	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
26	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
27	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
28	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
29	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
30	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
Maturity	₹ 4,80,000	₹ 8,37,592
NPV	₹ -1,75,352	₹ -28,615

If you die at 50

In this case the TROP gives ₹1 crore but not the premiums back since premium is returned only if you do not die. Here the normal plan also gives ₹1 crore but there is an additional ₹3.63 lakhs balance in the PPF account. The NPV is again higher in the normal + PPF case.

Year	TROP	Normal + PPF
1	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
2	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
3	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
4	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
5	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
6	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
7	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
8	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
9	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
10	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
11	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
12	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
13	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
14	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
15	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
16	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
17	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
18	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
19	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
20	₹ -18,880	₹ -10,593
21	₹ 1,00,00,000	₹ 1,03,63,511
NPV	₹ 22,15,116	₹ 23,90,701

If you die anytime during the validity of the policy

We show some NPV values below for death from year 1 to year 30 of the death case and in all years, the normal + PPF option is better financially.

Year	TROP	Normal + PPF	Normal has higher NPV
1	₹ 87,16,742	₹ 87,32,232	₹ 15,490
2	₹ 81,28,843	₹ 81,58,809	₹ 29,966
3	₹ 75,79,405	₹ 76,22,900	₹ 43,495
4	₹ 70,65,911	₹ 71,22,051	₹ 56,140
5	₹ 65,86,011	₹ 66,53,967	₹ 67,957
6	₹ 61,37,505	₹ 62,16,506	₹ 79,001
7	₹ 57,18,341	₹ 58,07,663	₹ 89,322
8	₹ 53,26,599	₹ 54,25,568	₹ 98,968
9	₹ 49,60,485	₹ 50,68,469	₹ 1,07,983
10	₹ 46,18,323	₹ 47,34,732	₹ 1,16,409
11	₹ 42,98,545	₹ 44,22,828	₹ 1,24,283
12	₹ 39,99,687	₹ 41,31,329	₹ 1,31,642
13	₹ 37,20,380	₹ 38,58,900	₹ 1,38,520
14	₹ 34,59,346	₹ 36,04,293	₹ 1,44,947
15	₹ 32,15,389	₹ 33,66,343	₹ 1,50,955
16	₹ 29,87,391	₹ 31,43,960	₹ 1,56,569
17	₹ 27,74,310	₹ 29,36,125	₹ 1,61,816
18	₹ 25,75,168	₹ 27,41,887	₹ 1,66,719
19	₹ 23,89,054	₹ 25,60,356	₹ 1,71,302
20	₹ 22,15,116	₹ 23,90,701	₹ 1,75,585
21	₹ 20,52,557	₹ 22,32,145	₹ 1,79,588
22	₹ 19,00,633	₹ 20,83,962	₹ 1,83,329
23	₹ 17,58,647	₹ 19,45,473	₹ 1,86,825
24	₹ 16,25,951	₹ 18,16,043	₹ 1,90,093
25	₹ 15,01,935	₹ 16,95,082	₹ 1,93,146
26	₹ 13,86,033	₹ 15,82,033	₹ 1,96,000
27	₹ 12,77,713	₹ 14,76,381	₹ 1,98,668
28	₹ 11,76,479	₹ 13,77,640	₹ 2,01,160
29	₹ 10,81,869	₹ 12,85,359	₹ 2,03,490
30	₹ 9,93,447	₹ 11,99,115	₹ 2,05,667

What's next? You can join the Arthgyaan WhatsApp community

You can stay updated on our latest content and learn about our webinars. Our community is fully private so that no one, other than the admin, can see your name or number. Also, we will not spam you.

For resident Indians 🇮🇳:

For NRIs 🇺🇸🇬🇧🇪🇺🇦🇺🇦🇪🇸🇬:

Share on WhatsApp:

To understand how this article can help you:

If you have a comment or question about this article

The following button will open a form with the link of this page populated for context:

If you liked this article, please leave us a rating

The following button will take you to Trustpilot:

Discover an article from the archives

Previous and next articles:

<p>This article explains the concept of NPV - a financial tool that helps you compare investment options to use in buying insurance, SGB and in many other cases.</p>

Calculator

How Net Present Value (NPV) Can Help You Make Smarter Financial Decisions

This article explains the concept of NPV - a financial tool that helps you compare investment options to use in buying insurance, SGB and in many other cases.

Published: 20 August 2023

7 MIN READ

Gold

Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB): Which Series is Best for You?

This article explains which Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB) series should be bought from the stock market if you are planning to invest in SGB.

Published: 27 August 2023

4 MIN READ

Latest articles:

<p>This article provides an alternative to the usual safe investments that retirees choose vs growing their wealth without taking market risk themselves.</p>

Senior Citizens Retirement

Can senior citizens get both safety and high returns from their retirement portfolio?

This article provides an alternative to the usual safe investments that retirees choose vs growing their wealth without taking market risk themselves.

Published: 22 December 2024

8 MIN READ

<p>This article simplifies compliance for US, Canada, UK, and Australia-based NRIs, covering FBAR, FATCA, PFIC, and T1135 requirements.</p>

NRI Tax

What NRIs Must Do With Indian Investments Before the Year-End? PFIC, FATCA, DTAA and ITR rules Simplified

This article simplifies compliance for US, Canada, UK, and Australia-based NRIs, covering FBAR, FATCA, PFIC, and T1135 requirements.

Published: 18 December 2024

6 MIN READ

Topics you will like:

Next steps:

1. Email me with any questions.

2. Use our goal-based investing template to prepare a financial plan for yourself.

Don't forget to share this article on WhatsApp or Twitter or post this to Facebook.

Discuss this post with us via Facebook or get regular bite-sized updates on Twitter.

Arthgyaan

Supporting everyone's personal finance journey